Discover the chance to own a true piece of Sag Harbor Village history with Holton House, located 2,100 ft from the center of the village. This charming 3 bed, 2 bath home remained in the same family since the mid-1800s, with only 1 owner since. Renowned for its association with Sag Harbor's famous "Tomato Lady" farmstand, this was her family home where she sold her beloved tomatoes. The entire downstairs underwent a meticulous renovation down to the studs in 2018, including updated electrical, plumbing, and central AC systems. The eat-in kitchen is a standout feature, marrying the original brick hearth with modern appliances. A generous covered front porch, recently reconstructed, offers a welcoming entrance, while the first floor also includes a guest bedroom and a full bath. Upstairs, the spacious primary bedroom boasts an en-suite bath, complemented by another guest bedroom. A shaded back patio overlooks the picturesque backyard, which is adorned with mature landscaping. The interior design, curated by 1818 Collective, adds a touch of contemporary elegance to this historic home. Holton House is ready for your personal touch and offers potential room for a pool, presenting an unbelievable investment opportunity or the chance to own one of the Village's legendary historic homes.

Property Details

  • MLS #291 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
  • TypeSingle Family Homes
  • StatusActive
  • Development
  • Subdivision
  • Sale TypeRegular Sale
  • Adjusted Size Sqft0
  • Lot Size7,405
  • Price / Sq.Ft.$0
  • Parking Spaces0
  • Swimming PoolNo
  • Days on Market
  • Year Built1880
  • Style
  • WaterfrontNo
  • FurnishedNo
  • Flooring Type2
  • Date Listed
  • HOA Fees
  • Cooling Type
  • Heating TypeFuel Electric
  • Taxes Year
  • Taxes$0


  • Central AC
  • Covered front porch
  • Eat-in kitchen

Interior Features

  • Dining
  • En Suite:
  • First Floor Bath
  • Hardwood Floor
  • Kitchen

Exterior Features

  • Outbuilding Shed
  • Sprinkler System

The multiple listing information is provided by the ® from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2024-present ®. All Rights Reserved. The information provided is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Listing courtesy of:

Real Estate IDX Powered by: IDX Boost